Siniša Kolarić, Ph.D.

Siniša is a design researcher, author and technologist dedicated to exploring the transformative potential of AI and its application across a wide range of design disciplines.

Published on July 2, 2025

IntroductionPermalink

Hot on the heels of Andrej Karpathy’s recent talk, imagine a world where your tools don’t just follow your commands — they anticipate them. This is the current state-of-art of AI interfaces, which are now being designed with four distinct modes of interaction, each offering a different degree of autonomy. These modes — no AI, ask AI, inline suggestions / autocomplete, and agent AI — are not just technical upgrades; they’re a paradigm shift in how humans and machines collaborate. Let’s dive into what each mode means, how they differ, and why they matter for your workflow.

1. No AI: The Traditional, Human-Centric ApproachPermalink

At the far end of the autonomy spectrum lies the no AI mode. This is the classic interface you’ve used for years — think of a text editor, a spreadsheet, or a basic search engine. Here, the user has full control over every action, and the system doesn’t intervene unless explicitly told to.

Why it matters:

  • Precision: Ideal for tasks requiring exact control, like coding or data entry.
  • Transparency: No ambiguity about what the system is doing.
  • Learning curve: Requires users to know the system’s limitations.

Example: A graphic designer using a vector graphics tool to manually adjust shapes without AI assistance.

2. Ask AI: The Human-in-the-Loop ModelPermalink

The ask AI mode is where users explicitly request help from the AI. It’s like asking a colleague for advice: you know what you need, and the AI provides a direct answer. This mode is useful when you want clarity or confirmation, but you’re still in the driver’s seat.

Why it matters:

  • Controlled collaboration: The AI acts as a helper, not a decision-maker.
  • Contextual accuracy: Ideal for complex queries where precision is key (e.g., explaining a technical concept).
  • Trust-building: Users can verify the AI’s responses before taking action.

Example: A researcher asking an AI to summarize a dense academic paper in plain language.

3. Inline Suggestions / Autocomplete: Proactive AssistancePermalink

The inline suggestions mode is where the AI anticipates your needs. Think of it as autocomplete in a search bar or a smart IDE that predicts the next line of code. This mode is designed to reduce friction by offering real-time help without requiring explicit requests.

Why it matters:

  • Efficiency: Saves time by eliminating the need to phrase queries.
  • Seamless integration: Works best in repetitive or routine tasks.
  • Learning from context: The AI adapts based on your past interactions.

Example: A writer using a word processor that suggests phrases or corrections as they type.

4. Agent AI: The Autonomous PartnerPermalink

At the top of the autonomy scale is agent AI, a self-sufficient system that can perform tasks independently, often without direct input from the user. This mode is like having a personal assistant who not only follows your instructions but also makes decisions on your behalf.

Why it matters:

  • Hands-off efficiency: Perfect for complex workflows (e.g., code refactoring and generation, scheduling, data analysis, or project management).
  • Adaptability: The AI learns from your habits and preferences over time.
  • Scalability: Handles multi-step tasks that would be tedious for humans.

Example: An AI agent that automatically augments your code base, organizes your calendar, books meetings, and sends reminders without you lifting a finger.

The Spectrum of Autonomy: Choosing the Right ModePermalink

The beauty of these four modes lies in their flexibility. They’re not mutually exclusive but rather part of a spectrum that allows users to tailor their experience. For instance:

  • A developer might use no AI for precise coding, inline suggestions for quick edits, and agent AI for automating repetitive tasks or generating new code.
  • A business user might rely on ask AI for strategic insights, agent AI for data-driven decisions, and inline suggestions for streamlining reports.

This adaptability means the future of AI interfaces isn’t about replacing human input but enhancing it. As these modes evolve, they’ll redefine productivity, creativity, and problem-solving. The key to leveraging them effectively is understanding when to step back (no AI), when to ask for help (ask AI), when to let the AI guide you (inline suggestions), and when to trust it to act on your behalf (agent AI).

So, which mode will you choose? The answer might just depend on how much you trust your AI partner – and how much you want to let it help you with your work.

ReferencesPermalink

Updated: